Four stages, usually about two weeks start to finish, and the only one that ever surprises anybody is the title search. Here’s each stage and what can go sideways in it.
Stage one: the conversation
Ten minutes on the phone. Where the house is, what shape it’s in, and what you’re actually trying to accomplish.
That third one shapes everything else. A hard move-out date and an estate nobody can sign for are two different problems needing two different answers. I’ve had people turn down a higher number because a faster closing would have wrecked their move.
What goes sideways here is not telling us something you already know about. A lien, an heir who hasn’t signed, an addition nobody permitted, a code case you’ve been ignoring.
None of that scares us off. All of it changes the timeline, and finding out at day 25 instead of day one is how a smooth deal turns into a renegotiation. Telling us costs you nothing.
Stage two: the walkthrough
One visit, the whole house, including the parts people would rather skip. Don’t clean, don’t haul anything off, don’t get a roof quote.
Roof, electrical panel, plumbing, and water, roughly in that order. Water gets the most attention because it hides. The stain on a closet ceiling. A cabinet floor gone soft at the back under the sink. A baseboard that stopped sitting flat.
What goes sideways here is a drive-by instead of a real look. That’s how buyers end up “discovering” something later and using it to renegotiate, and it’s why we look at everything up front instead.
Ask any buyer whether they’re actually walking the property before they finalize a number. If they aren’t, the number isn’t final no matter what they call it.
Stage three: the number
Recent closed sales on houses like yours, not asking prices. Minus what this one realistically needs. Minus what it costs us to hold, fix, and resell it. Minus a margin, because that’s how I make a living and hiding it would be worse than saying it.
All four get said out loud in your kitchen.
Push back on the repair estimate. That’s where the room is. Ask what specifically is being priced in and roughly what each line costs. If a buyer can’t answer item by item, they made the number up, and that’s true of anybody you talk to including us.

Stage four: title and closing
What actually sets the date
Title, almost always. We’ve closed in as little as seven days, and when that happens it’s because the search came back clean rather than because anybody hustled.
What stretches it: an heir’s signature nobody obtained, an old judgment against a previous owner, a contractor’s lien from 2014 that never got released, or a payoff department that takes eleven days to produce a letter. None of that is fixable by wanting it faster, and it’s true regardless of who’s buying.
So a promised closing date before the title search is back is a guess. Ask what happens to your date if title turns something up.
The local wrinkle
Municipal items add days, and which ones depends on where you sit. Inside the incorporated Town of Orange Park there may be a utility account to settle and a town lien search to run. In Bellair, Lakeside, or Oakleaf that search goes through Clay County instead, and in Oakleaf there’s a community development district assessment to reconcile on top of association dues.
None of it is difficult. It’s sequential, and each step runs on somebody else’s turnaround time.
At the table
You pick the date, within reason. No commission because there’s no agent, no lender fees because there’s no loan, and we cover standard closing costs on our purchases. What we agree on is essentially what you get.
Leave whatever you don’t want. Furniture, the garage, the attic. Already in the budget.
What we do between the offer and the closing
Mostly waiting on other people, which is worth knowing so the quiet stretch doesn’t feel like something went wrong.
The title company runs the search and orders payoffs. Your servicer produces a payoff letter on its own schedule and nobody can speed that up. If there’s an association involved, an estoppel letter gets ordered, and those take what they take. If the property is inside the town limits there may be a municipal lien search on top of the county one.
You’ll hear from us during that stretch rather than going dark. And if the search turns something up, we’ll tell you what it is and what it means. What we won’t do is treat it as an opening to renegotiate a number we already agreed on, and that’s a question worth asking every buyer before you sign: what happens to my price if title finds something.
Most searches come back clean. The ones that don’t are usually a surprise to the owner too, especially on an inherited property where nobody has looked at the records in twenty years.
How this compares to the other path
A marketed sale usually shows a bigger number on the sign, and I’d say that plainly rather than let you find out later.
What comes off it: commission on both sides, whatever the inspection turns up on a house of this age, and the payments you keep making while it sits. March 2026 data put Clay County’s median days on market at 52 just to get under contract, and April data showed the typical seller closing at around 94.8% of asking.
Both are real options. The comparison worth making is what lands in your account and when, not what goes on a sign. The current figures are in the market report if you want to run it yourself, and the full process is written out here.
Check us before you start
Look the company up on the Florida Division of Corporations to confirm it exists and how long it’s been active. Then search the Clay County Property Appraiser records for the name and see what’s actually been purchased.
A company that genuinely buys houses leaves recorded purchases behind it. One that flips contracts to other people leaves almost none, and that gap is where sellers get hurt. Six years and well over a hundred houses is a claim you can verify in ten minutes, which is exactly why I keep telling people to go verify it.
When you’re ready, We Buy Houses Orange Park will come look and give you a real number with the reasoning attached.
Josiah Murdaugh grew up in Orange Park and spent 11 years as a licensed real estate agent before he started buying houses directly. He has bought more than a hundred since. About We Buy Houses Orange Park.