Faster than most landlords fear and slower than any of them want. Florida’s residential eviction process is genuinely more efficient than a lot of states, and it is still a court proceeding with steps you cannot skip.
If you’re weighing an eviction against just selling a tenant occupied house in Orange Park, here’s the sequence in order so you can price both.
I’m not an attorney and this isn’t legal advice. Eviction rules are specific and the consequences of getting a step wrong are real. Talk to a lawyer before you serve anything.
Step one: the notice
Florida requires written notice before you can file anything, and for nonpayment of rent that’s a demand giving the tenant a short window to either pay or vacate.
The notice has to be correct. Wrong form, wrong number of days, wrong delivery method, and a judge can send you back to the beginning. That’s where most self-filed evictions lose their time, not in the court part.
Count the days properly and document how you delivered it. This is the cheapest step to get right and the most expensive to redo.
Step two: filing with the court
If the deadline passes with no payment and no departure, you file an eviction action with the county court.
Florida’s process for residential nonpayment moves relatively quickly compared to a foreclosure, which is a lawsuit in circuit court that can run months. Eviction is designed to be faster. It’s still a filing fee, a service of process, and a court’s calendar.
Step three: the tenant’s response window
The tenant gets a short period to respond. In a nonpayment case, Florida generally requires a tenant who wants to contest to deposit the disputed rent into the court registry.
That requirement is significant in your favor, because a tenant who isn’t paying you frequently can’t deposit it either, and the case moves. A tenant who does deposit it has bought themselves a contested hearing.
Step four: judgment and the writ
If you prevail, the court issues a judgment for possession and then a writ of possession. The sheriff posts the writ, the tenant gets a final short window, and then the sheriff executes it.
That last part is the piece landlords misunderstand most. You do not remove the tenant. The sheriff does. Which brings us to the thing worth saying loudest.

What you absolutely cannot do
Self-help eviction is illegal in Florida and it is the fastest way to turn a manageable problem into an expensive one.
Do not change the locks. Do not shut off the power or the water. Do not remove their belongings. Do not take the door off. Every one of those creates liability that dwarfs whatever you’re owed in back rent, and a tenant who was going to lose the case can end up with a claim against you instead.
I understand the temptation completely. Somebody is living in your property for free and the process feels slow. Do it correctly anyway.
What it actually costs you
Add it up honestly, because this is the number that should drive your decision.
Filing fees, service costs, and an attorney if you use one. The rent you’re not collecting for the whole period. The mortgage, taxes at roughly 15.05 mills countywide, and insurance you’re paying regardless. Then the turnover after: cleaning, repairs, and vacancy while you re-rent.
Then ask the honest question. After all of that, are you going to rent it again?
Because if the answer is no, you just spent months and real money preparing a property for a sale you could have made in its current condition. That’s the calculation most landlords never run, and it’s the one that matters.
The security deposit rules have their own deadlines
Separate from the eviction and easy to get wrong while you’re focused on getting somebody out.
Florida sets specific requirements for how a landlord handles a security deposit after a tenancy ends, including written notice of any claim against it and a short window to send it. Miss the deadline and you can lose the right to claim against the deposit entirely, even when the damage is real and documented.
So handle it on its own timeline rather than treating it as cleanup after the eviction finishes. Send the notice properly, keep proof of how you sent it, and be precise about what you’re claiming and why. A vague claim invites a dispute you’ll lose.
Worth an hour with a landlord-tenant attorney if you’ve never done it. The rules aren’t complicated, they’re just unforgiving about timing, which describes most of Florida landlord law. The Florida Bar’s consumer resources are a reasonable starting point.
If the property has been damaged too
Document everything before you touch anything. Photos and video of every room, timestamped, before a single bag gets hauled out.
You’ll need it for the security deposit accounting, which has its own Florida deadlines and requirements, and for any claim against the tenant. Once you start cleaning, you’re arguing from memory against somebody who remembers it differently.
Separate ordinary wear from actual damage. Worn carpet in a traffic lane after four years is wear. Holes, missing fixtures, and pet damage into the subfloor are damage. The third category is the expensive one: things that got worse because nobody reported them, like a slow leak under a sink that ran for eight months. There’s more on that side here.
Can you sell with the tenant still in place?
Yes, and it’s worth understanding before you commit to the eviction path.
In Florida an existing lease generally survives a sale, so a buyer inherits the tenant and the terms. That shrinks your buyer pool considerably, because most retail buyers want to move in. Investors will buy it and they’ll price the situation.
The practical problem with a marketed sale is access. A tenant who won’t cooperate with showings makes a traditional listing close to impossible, and having the legal right of access doesn’t help much when a buyer is walking through a hostile house. That kills deals and no agent can fix it for you.
How to decide
Want to keep owning it, tenant is the only problem, and the property is otherwise fine? Evict properly, with an attorney, and re-rent. That’s the right answer and the process works.
Already tired of being a landlord, or the property needs work you don’t want to fund, or this is the third turnover in five years? Then the eviction is months of cost and effort spent getting a property ready for a decision you’ve already made. Selling with the tenant in place skips all of it.
After six years and well over a hundred houses, most landlords who call me aren’t calling about the tenant. The tenant is what finally made the decision get made. We Buy Houses Orange Park buys tenant-occupied properties, including ones where the tenant isn’t paying and isn’t leaving, and we handle that part ourselves.
Before you do anything on your own, the Florida Bar’s consumer resources are a reasonable starting point, and an hour with a landlord-tenant attorney costs far less than a wrongful eviction claim.
Josiah Murdaugh grew up in Orange Park and spent 11 years as a licensed real estate agent before he started buying houses directly. He has bought more than a hundred since. About We Buy Houses Orange Park.